blog

Quote Cart

View your shopping cart.

Newsletters of Sustainable Lighting

Lighting design – visual comfort

Lighting design – visual comfort

It is important to understand that there is not a clear-cut line between comfort and glare. For instance, many people will happily work away in a daylight space with a window, turning their backs to the sun and avoiding the glare while generally enjoying a cheerful space. In other cases, people will tolerate some glare as long as it contributes to an overall impact of sparkle (see Sparkle) or a festive mood. Yet a modest difference in brightness caused by an unattractive unchanging source like a lensed troffer is often deemed too much glare.

In an attempt to quantify the visual comfort of direct luminaires in a space, Visual Comfort Probability (VCP) was developed. VCP is a calculation taking into account the relative brightness of a lighting system from a given viewing angle, resulting in the likelihood (as a percent) that a lighting system will be visually comfortable from a glare control standpoint. VCP data were confirmed experimentally using uniform layouts of lensed fluorescent luminaires. While it is typical practice to extrapolate the VCP concept to apply it to various size louvers and luminous ceilings, it should be noted that VCP data have not been experimentally confirmed using these systems. As such, one should be cautious in using VCP to evaluate the potential visual comfort of lighting systems using other than lensed luminaires, making it of limited practical use.

In other words, there is acceptable glare and unacceptable glare from a comfort standpoint and the definition is not quantitative but qualitative. Discomfort glare can be the result of either direct glare or reflected glare. Overhead glare is discomfort glare caused by a glare source above the normal field of view.

For a long time, it was believed that discomfort glare could only occur with a glare source in the field of view and that the further away from the centre of view, the less the glare sensation. By this reasoning, working under an open parabolic luminaire should not be uncomfortable because the bare lamps are above the field of view. However, many people do express discomfort due to the brightness of the lamps in this situation. And there is a wide range of individual sensitivity to this overhead glare condition. This is because the field of view is not an abrupt cut-off, nor consistent between individuals. Likewise, the sensation of brightness does not end abruptly, but diminishes. The overhead glare sensation is believed to be a result of the interaction of the high-angle light with the viewer’s facial physiology – light scattering at the cornea and eyebrow and reflecting into the eye from nose, cheekbones and other facial objects such as bangs or eyeglasses.

There are several variables associated with the level of discomfort from a glare source:

  • Luminance of the Source: The greater the luminance, the greater the discomfort. Luminances greater than 16,000 Cd/sqm are considered to be glaring by most people. For reference, T8 linear fluorescent lamps are a little less than 12,000 Cd/sqm and T5 standard output linear fluorescent lamps are a little higher than 16,000 Cd/sqm. Therefore, luminaires with exposed T5 and T5HO lamps should be avoided.
  • Luminance of the Immediate Area Surrounding the Source: The greater the contrast, the greater the discomfort.
  • Size of the Source: The larger the size, the greater the discomfort.
  • Deviation of the Source from the Line of Sight: The closer into the line of sight, the greater the discomfort. Commonly the vertical field of view is considered to be 70 degrees below horizontal up to roughly 53 degrees above the horizontal. Although it may still be a cause of discomfort above 53 degrees in the case of Overhead Glare.

Spectral Composition: Current research is evaluating the impact of spectral composition on glare sensation. Theory is that the higher the color temperature and the stronger the short wave length composition (blue portion of the spectrum), the greater the discomfort. For long term occupancy and commercial spaces, be more concerned about glare caused by fluorescent lamps, lenses, and other overly bright sources of light. (Luminaires & Distribution/Luminaire Components provides more information about glare issues related to specific types of luminaires.) Be less concerned about the glare in interior spaces of short-term duration sunlight and small point sources like incandescent filaments. Be most concerned about sources of glare in relation to stationary tasks when the building occupants cannot easily relocate themselves or their task.

Direct glare is caused by a view of the light source, often with high contrast to the surroundings. While the bare light bulb is technically the most efficient “luminaire” because it has no internal losses, it is a poor choice in almost every application because the glare from the bulb walls is visually unpleasant. Thus, the control and distribution of light from a source is an essential characteristic of its visual efficiency. Glare is associated not just with lamps, but also with daylight, especially when one is exposed to low angle, direct sunlight. Any excessively bright source, not just electric lamps, but also low-angle sunlight or overly bright luminance, can cause glare from windows or skylight diffusers. Thus IES design guides promote modest ratios of brightness.

Luminance is a very important concept in lighting, since luminance is what we actually see. Rigorously, luminance is defined to be the ratio of the intensity of light produced by a surface in a given direction to the projected area of the emitting surface. In International System of Units (SI), luminance is generally expressed as candelas/square meter (cd/sqm). In Inch-Pound (IP) units, luminance should generally be expressed in candelas/square foot (cd/sqft). The foot-lambert unit for luminance that has been used in the past has been deprecated and should be avoided. Brightness is used to describe the strength of the perception caused by viewing surfaces (or volumes). Brightness is related to luminance, but takes account of the fact that there is not a linear relationship between relative luminance values and perceived brightness. For example, a surface with a luminance of 100 cd/sqm will not appear twice as bright as a surface of 50 cd/sqm.

Occupant control of light sources is an important strategy in reducing the impact of glare. Adjustable task lights and individually dimming ceiling luminaires provide control over glare conditions from electric lighting. Individually controllable window blinds and curtains provide occupants with the opportunity to adjust lighting conditions to their particular needs and wants. When feasible, such personal control of lights will greatly reduce the negative impacts of potentially glaring sources. For more about controls, refer to Lighting Controls.

http://algonline.org/docs/index.php?discomfort-overhead-glare

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

Ridiculous story there. What occurred after? Good luck!

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

If you are going for finest contents likoe myself, just payy a quick visit this website all the time as it givs quality contents, thanks

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

Generally I do not read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very compelled me to check out and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very great article.

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

I am in fact glad tο glance at thiѕ website posts ѡhich carries tons oof helpful data, tɦanks ffor prtoviding sսch data.

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

I really like it when folks come together and share views. Great site, continue the good work!

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

Excellent site you have got here.. It's hard to find excellent writing like yours nowadays. I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

Having read this I believed it was rather enlightening. I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this content together. I once again find myself spending a significant amount of time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worthwhile!

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

I enjoy what youu guy ttend tο be up too. Thhis type of clever work and reporting!

Ҡeep սp the fantastic wօrks guys I've incorporated ʏߋu guys to blogroll.

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

A fascinating discussion is without a doubt worth comment. I think that you ought to write more on this issue, it may not be described as a taboo matter but usually folks don't discuss such subjects. To another! Kind regards!!

Lighting design – visual comfort | Technilux Lighting

Just desire to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your post is simply spectacular and i can assume you're an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the rewarding work.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <strong> <em> <p>

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
Technilux Lighting
  • Address Unit 18, 41-49 Norcal Road,
  • Nunawading, Victoria, Australia
  • ABN 69 065 653 885
  • Telephone +61 03-9872-7688
  • Fax +61 03-9874-8299
Technilux Lighting Partners Technilux Lighting Partners Technilux Lighting Partners Technilux Lighting Partners Technilux Lighting Partners Technilux Lighting Partners